Small businesses that want published base-plus-per-person pricing with payroll, benefits and HR in one product and are willing to move to the Plus tier for multi-state payroll.
Watch for: Simple plan covers payroll in one state only; multi-state payroll starts at Plus ($80/mo + $12/mo per person).
Businesses already using QuickBooks Online that want payroll in the same product, with next-day deposit on the entry plan and same-day on higher tiers.
Watch for: Time tracking and most HR tools require Workforce Premium ($88/mo + $13/employee list) or Elite.
Businesses that want a large established provider with four RUN tiers scaling from payroll to HR and are comfortable requesting a quote.
Watch for: No prices are published; every plan requires a quote.
Businesses that want a long-established payroll provider with HR and PEO upgrade paths and are comfortable obtaining a custom quote.
Watch for: Pricing is not published; a sales quote is required (per search-indexed vendor text).
Businesses already using Square POS or the Square Team App that want payroll fed by Square timecards, or that only pay contractors.
Watch for: Mailing paper W-2s/1099s costs $3 per form per year.
Cost-sensitive small businesses in one state, including those willing to file their own payroll taxes on the Basic plan.
Watch for: Basic Payroll does not file or deposit payroll taxes for you.
Very small single-state employers that want a low base price and are comfortable paying separately for year-end forms and integrations.
Watch for: Year-end W-2/1099-NEC filing costs a $50 base fee plus $5 per form, billed annually.
Small employers that want payroll with multi-state filing included and a clear upgrade path to a PEO from the same vendor.
Watch for: Advanced time tracking is an $8/month per employee add-on.
Very small businesses already using Wave's accounting and invoicing that want basic payroll with tax filing at a single flat price.
Watch for: 1099 filings are excluded from the tax service (forms are generated only).
Companies that want payroll as one module of a broader HR/IT platform and will obtain a custom per-employee quote.
Watch for: Only a starting price ($8 per employee per month plus an undisclosed base fee) is published; actual cost requires a quote.
Small businesses that want one payroll plan rather than tiers; OnPay's price and inclusions could not be confirmed on its own pricing page for this comparison.
Watch for: Pricing could not be confirmed on the vendor's pricing page in this check; one onpay.com page reportedly says pricing 'starts at $55 per month', which conflicts with $49 + $6 unless it means one worker.