Skip to content
Payroll Software for Small Businesses
Sections
Payroll software comparison

Provider pricing pages checked . 7 of 11 confirmed, 1 could not be read.

QuickBooks Payroll vs Square Payroll: Payroll Software for Small Businesses

At list price, Square Payroll costs less than QuickBooks Payroll for a five-employee small business: $85 a month for QuickBooks Payroll against $65 for Square Payroll.

Is QuickBooks Payroll or Square Payroll cheaper for a small business?

At list price, Square Payroll costs less than QuickBooks Payroll for a five-employee small business: $85 a month for QuickBooks Payroll against $65 for Square Payroll. The gap changes with headcount because each provider splits its price differently between the base fee and the per-employee fee.

Entry planQuickBooks PayrollSquare Payroll
PlanWorkforce PayrollFull-service payroll
Base fee / month$50$35
Per employee / month$7$6
1 employee$57$41
5 employees$85$65
10 employees$120$95
25 employees$225$185

How do QuickBooks Payroll and Square Payroll differ on features?

FeatureQuickBooks PayrollSquare Payroll
Files federal payroll taxesYesYes
Files state payroll taxesYesYes
Available in all 50 statesNot statedNot stated
Multi-state payroll on the entry planNot statedYes
Unlimited payroll runsNot statedYes
W-2 and 1099 filing includedNot statedYes
Contractor-only planNot statedYes
Built-in time trackingYesYes
Benefits administrationYesYes
Workers' comp integrationYesYes
HR toolsYesYes
Mobile appYesYes
PEO optionNot statedNot stated

Which small businesses suit QuickBooks Payroll, and which suit Square Payroll?

QuickBooks Payroll: QuickBooks Payroll suits a small business that already keeps its books in QuickBooks Online and wants payroll entries to post there without an integration. The pricing page refers to extra state tax filing and per-contractor fees without giving amounts, so ask for those before comparing on price.

Square Payroll: Square Payroll suits a small business that already takes payments or tracks hours with Square, and it has a separate contractor-only plan with no base fee for businesses that pay only 1099 workers. Multi-state payroll and unlimited pay runs are included in the full-service plan.

What are the limits of QuickBooks Payroll and Square Payroll?

  • QuickBooks Payroll: Time tracking and most HR tools require Workforce Premium ($88/mo + $13/employee list) or Elite.
  • QuickBooks Payroll: Offer terms reference additional state tax filing fees and per-contractor fees whose amounts are not shown on the pricing page.
  • QuickBooks Payroll: Tax penalty protection is limited to the Elite plan.
  • Square Payroll: Mailing paper W-2s/1099s costs $3 per form per year.
  • Square Payroll: Health insurance, 401(k) and workers' comp are add-ons through partners.
  • Square Payroll: Only QuickBooks Online is listed as an accounting integration on the pricing page.

Full detail: QuickBooks Payroll review and Square Payroll review. Provider pages: QuickBooks Payroll, Square Payroll.

Questions about QuickBooks Payroll vs Square Payroll

Is QuickBooks Payroll or Square Payroll cheaper?

At list price, Square Payroll costs less than QuickBooks Payroll for a five-employee small business: $85 a month for QuickBooks Payroll against $65 for Square Payroll.

What is the main difference between QuickBooks Payroll and Square Payroll?

Their published feature lists match on the points this site tracks; the difference is mainly price and plan structure.

Do QuickBooks Payroll and Square Payroll both file payroll taxes?

QuickBooks Payroll: yes for federal, yes for state. Square Payroll: yes for federal, yes for state. Filing can depend on the plan.

Compare all payroll software for small businesses

Get a shortlist by email

Say how many people you pay and where. You get one reply listing the payroll software that fits, with what each would cost you a month.

Used only to reply to this request. Privacy.