Provider pricing pages checked . 7 of 11 confirmed, 1 could not be read.
Gusto vs Square Payroll: Payroll Software for Small Businesses
At list price, Square Payroll costs less than Gusto for a five-employee small business: $79 a month for Gusto against $65 for Square Payroll.
Is Gusto or Square Payroll cheaper for a small business?
At list price, Square Payroll costs less than Gusto for a five-employee small business: $79 a month for Gusto against $65 for Square Payroll. The gap changes with headcount because each provider splits its price differently between the base fee and the per-employee fee.
| Entry plan | Gusto | Square Payroll |
|---|---|---|
| Plan | Simple | Full-service payroll |
| Base fee / month | $49 | $35 |
| Per employee / month | $6 | $6 |
| 1 employee | $55 | $41 |
| 5 employees | $79 | $65 |
| 10 employees | $109 | $95 |
| 25 employees | $199 | $185 |
How do Gusto and Square Payroll differ on features?
| Feature | Gusto | Square Payroll |
|---|---|---|
| Files federal payroll taxes | Yes | Yes |
| Files state payroll taxes | Yes | Yes |
| Available in all 50 states | Not stated | Not stated |
| Multi-state payroll on the entry plan | No | Yes |
| Unlimited payroll runs | Yes | Yes |
| W-2 and 1099 filing included | Yes | Yes |
| Contractor-only plan | Not stated | Yes |
| Built-in time tracking | Yes | Yes |
| Benefits administration | Yes | Yes |
| Workers' comp integration | Yes | Yes |
| HR tools | Yes | Yes |
| Mobile app | Yes | Yes |
| PEO option | Not stated | Not stated |
Which small businesses suit Gusto, and which suit Square Payroll?
Gusto: Gusto suits a single-state small business that wants payroll taxes filed, year-end forms included and benefits in the same product. A business paying people in more than one state needs the Plus plan, which changes the price considerably.
Square Payroll: Square Payroll suits a small business that already takes payments or tracks hours with Square, and it has a separate contractor-only plan with no base fee for businesses that pay only 1099 workers. Multi-state payroll and unlimited pay runs are included in the full-service plan.
What are the limits of Gusto and Square Payroll?
- Gusto: Simple plan covers payroll in one state only; multi-state payroll starts at Plus ($80/mo + $12/mo per person).
- Gusto: Next-day pay costs extra on Simple; same-day/instant pay cost $90/$100 per payroll outside Premium.
- Gusto: State tax registration is a paid add-on on every plan (pricing varies by state).
- Square Payroll: Mailing paper W-2s/1099s costs $3 per form per year.
- Square Payroll: Health insurance, 401(k) and workers' comp are add-ons through partners.
- Square Payroll: Only QuickBooks Online is listed as an accounting integration on the pricing page.
Full detail: Gusto review and Square Payroll review. Provider pages: Gusto, Square Payroll.
Questions about Gusto vs Square Payroll
Is Gusto or Square Payroll cheaper?
At list price, Square Payroll costs less than Gusto for a five-employee small business: $79 a month for Gusto against $65 for Square Payroll.
What is the main difference between Gusto and Square Payroll?
Based on their published feature lists, they differ on: multi-state payroll on the entry plan (Gusto: no; Square Payroll: yes).
Do Gusto and Square Payroll both file payroll taxes?
Gusto: yes for federal, yes for state. Square Payroll: yes for federal, yes for state. Filing can depend on the plan.