Payroll software lets you run payroll yourself with the calculations and filings automated. An accountant or bookkeeper runs it for you. A PEO goes further and becomes a co-employer of your staff, bundling payroll with benefits and HR.
How do payroll software, an accountant and a PEO differ?
They differ in who does the work, what else is bundled and what it costs.
| Payroll software | Accountant or bookkeeper | PEO | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who runs each payroll | You | They do | You enter, PEO processes |
| Tax deposits and filings | Provider, on full-service plans | Accountant, often via software | PEO, under its accounts |
| Benefits and HR | Add-on or higher tier | Not usually | Included |
| Published price | From $29 to $50 a month plus $5 to $8 per person | Not published | Justworks: $79 or $124 per employee per month |
When is payroll software enough for a small business?
Payroll software is enough when the business mainly needs people paid correctly and taxes filed. That covers most small employers, including those with staff in several states, since multi-state filing is a feature or add-on of ordinary payroll software.
When does an accountant make more sense?
An accountant makes sense when the owner does not want to approve payroll at all, or when payroll is tangled up with other questions such as an S corporation owner’s salary. The accountant’s fee comes on top of whatever software they use.
When does a PEO make more sense?
A PEO makes sense when benefits and HR compliance are the real problem. Justworks, for example, sells payroll-only at $50 a month plus $8 per employee, and PEO plans at $79 and $124 per employee per month with no base fee. For ten employees that is $130 a month against $790 or $1,240.
Key takeaway Nobody chooses a PEO for payroll. They choose it for benefits and take payroll with it.
ADP, Paychex, Rippling and Justworks all sell a PEO alongside payroll software, so starting with software does not close off the option.
Does outsourcing remove the employer’s responsibility?
No. The IRS states that employers who outsource payroll generally remain responsible for deposits and filings. Check that a provider is bonded or offers a written accuracy guarantee, and keep access to your own IRS account to confirm deposits are made.
Key takeaways
- Software: you approve each run; published prices start at $29 to $50 a month plus a per-person fee.
- Accountant: someone else runs it; fees are set locally and not published.
- PEO: co-employment with benefits and HR; Justworks publishes $79 and $124 per employee per month.
- The choice turns on benefits and HR needs more than on payroll itself.
References
- Justworks pricing · Justworks
- Third party payer arrangements – Professional employer organizations · Internal Revenue Service
- Outsourcing payroll and third party payers · Internal Revenue Service
How this page was put together
Tax rates, thresholds and deadlines are taken from the government publications listed under References and apply to the year stated beside each figure. Provider prices come from each provider's own pricing page. This is general information for US small businesses, not tax or legal advice; rules vary by state and situation.