Skip to content
Payroll Software for Small Businesses
Sections
Basicspayrollsoftwareforsmallbusinesses.com

Full-Service vs Self-Service Payroll Software

Full-service payroll software deposits and files your payroll taxes; self-service payroll software only calculates them and leaves deposits and returns to you.

Published · 2 min read · By Payroll Software for Small Businesses

Full-service payroll software deposits your payroll taxes and files the returns for you. Self-service payroll software calculates the same numbers and stops there, leaving every deposit and filing to the business.

What does full-service payroll software do that self-service does not?

Full-service payroll software takes the tax money out of your account on payday, deposits it with the IRS and state agencies, and files the quarterly and annual returns. With self-service software you get a report of what is owed and do those steps yourself.

Task Self-service Full-service
Calculate pay and withholdings Software Software
Federal tax deposits You Provider
Form 941 each quarter, Form 940 each year You Provider
State withholding and unemployment returns You Provider
Track deposit schedule and due dates You Provider

How much cheaper is self-service payroll software?

Self-service is cheaper by $9 to $20 a month in base fee where both are published. Patriot charges $17 plus $4 per worker for Basic against $37 plus $5 for Full Service. SurePayroll charges $20 plus $4 for No Tax Filing against $29 plus $7 for Full Service.

For five employees that is $37 against $62 a month at Patriot, and $40 against $64 at SurePayroll.

What work does self-service payroll leave you with?

Self-service leaves a small employer with a deposit after every payday or every month, four Forms 941, one Form 940, the state equivalents and year-end forms. The deposit schedule and deadlines guide lists the dates.

Key takeaway Self-service saves a few hundred dollars a year and hands you the part of payroll that carries the penalties.

Who should choose self-service payroll software?

Self-service fits an owner who already files payroll returns confidently, or whose accountant does, and who wants software only for the arithmetic and pay stubs. It is a poor fit for a first-time employer.

Who should choose full-service payroll software?

Full-service fits nearly every other small business, and it is the only kind most providers sell. The best payroll software comparison uses each provider’s cheapest plan that files taxes, so its prices are like for like.

Key takeaways

  1. The difference is who deposits and files: the provider or you.
  2. Published self-file plans save $9 to $20 a month in base fee.
  3. Self-file leaves you with deposits on a fixed schedule and at least five federal filings a year.
  4. Most small businesses buy full-service.

References

  1. Patriot Software pricing · Patriot Software
  2. SurePayroll pricing · SurePayroll
  3. Failure to deposit penalty · Internal Revenue Service

How this page was put together

Tax rates, thresholds and deadlines are taken from the government publications listed under References and apply to the year stated beside each figure. Provider prices come from each provider's own pricing page. This is general information for US small businesses, not tax or legal advice; rules vary by state and situation.

Common questions

Is full-service payroll worth it for a small business?

For most small businesses, yes. The published price difference is $9 to $20 a month in base fee, while a single deposit more than 15 days late costs 10% of the amount.

Which payroll software has a self-file plan?

Of the providers compared here, Patriot (Basic Payroll, $17 a month plus $4 per worker) and SurePayroll (No Tax Filing, $20 plus $4 per employee) publish self-file plans.

Can I switch from self-service to full-service later?

Yes. Both Patriot and SurePayroll sell a full-service plan alongside the self-file one, so the change is an upgrade with the same provider.

Compare payroll software for your small business

Get a shortlist by email

Say how many people you pay and where. You get one reply listing the payroll software that fits, with what each would cost you a month.

Used only to reply to this request. Privacy.